Prophecy Unlimited

There have been times as I read a prophecy book that I come across some phrasing that makes me shake my head.  I’ll read something to the effect of, “There can only be one fulfillment of a prophecy.”  My thought is, “Oh really?  Where in the scripture did you find that principle?”  Some people just make up the rules as they go along, as if prophecy can be contained by a set of rules.  Now to be fair, there are many instances where a prophecy will only be fulfilled one time.  For instance, the prophecy of the virgin birth: Christ will only be born of a virgin one time; Christ’s death on the cross:  Christ will only die once for the sins of the world.  These prophecies have only one fulfillment.

However, there are prophecies of another nature.  Some have an ongoing type of fulfillment.  Understanding the meaning of the Greek word used here will help.  The word has the idea of making full or brought to an overflowing.  Some people mistakenly think that fulfillment means completion, and that is not the case.  When a prophecy is fulfilled, it is made full, as in, it is brought to the point of overflowing off the pages of scripture into the present time and space where one is standing.  When the virgin birth was fulfilled, it was brought off the pages of Isaiah’s prophecy into the very lives of Mary and Joseph.  When something is fulfilled, there can be no denying that it is occurring.  Other uses of the term include being filled with the Holy Spirit, Acts2:2, filling Jerusalem with a certain doctrine, Acts 5:28, Satan filling someone’s heart, Acts 5:3.  It is obvious that these examples can have more than one fulfillment.  It is with that mindset that we look at our next selection in the Tax Collector’s Guide to Fulfilled Prophecy.

Matthew 2:16  Then Herod, when he saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, became furious, and he sent and killed all the male children in Bethlehem and in all that region who were two years old or under, according to the time that he had ascertained from the wise men.  17  Then was fulfilled what was spoken by the prophet Jeremiah:  18  “A voice was heard in Ramah, weeping and loud lamentation, Rachel weeping for her children; she refused to be comforted, because they are no more.” 

If you read Jeremiah 31:15 by itself, you would be at a loss at to comprehend why Matthew chose this one verse out of the entire prophets as being fulfilled when Herod slaughtered these baby boys.  However, if you examine Jeremiah 30-31 in its entirety, it becomes all too obvious.  Jeremiah foresees the coming time of Jacob’s trouble which will be characterized by foreign rule instead of having their own king.  Yet in spite of this, God will deliver them out of it, and instead of serving foreign rulers, they will serve the Davidic Messiah, see Jeremiah 30:6-9.  This period of time begins with the Babylonian captivity especially with the slaying of King Zedekiah and ends with the reign of the Messiah over Israel.  The entire oracle of Jeremiah 30-31 explains this theme repeatedly revealing additional details, such as returning from captivity and dispersion, 30:10, 18, 31:8; a return to autonomous theocracy, 30:21-22; the correction and repentance of the nation of Israel, 31:18-19; even entering into a new covenant relationship with the LORD, 31:31-34.  With this in mind, let’s examine the portion of Jeremiah 31 that Matthew quotes as being fulfilled in the days of wicked King Herod.

Jeremiah 31:15
Thus says the LORD:
“A voice is heard in Ramah,
lamentation and bitter weeping.
Rachel is weeping for her children;
she refuses to be comforted for her children,
because they are no more.”

16  Thus says the LORD:
“Keep your voice from weeping,
and your eyes from tears,
for there is a reward for your work,
declares the LORD,
and they shall come back from the land of the enemy.

17  There is hope for your future,
declares the LORD,
and your children shall come back to their own country.

I am following the KJV in regards to the division of the passage which marks verses 15-17 as belonging to one paragraph, but following the ESV for translation and poetic line division.  Each translation seems to have their own ideas as to how the passage should be divided.  In looking at the language, it seems that verses 15-17 belong together because the weeping of verse 15 carries over to verse 16 and the children slain in verse 15 are returning in verse 17.  Jeremiah’s vision for the future based on verses 15-17 is as follows.  The time of Jacob’s trouble will be characterized by the senseless slaughter of the children of Israel.  Rachel here is metaphoric for all the mothers in Israel, she being one of the chief matriarchs, [much like Israel and Jacob are metaphoric for the entire nation even though they are the names of one man].  Rachel is heard weeping and refuses to be comforted during this time because there is no comfort.  It is an ongoing period of persecution and trouble against the children of Israel for which there is no way out except at the extreme end when Israel enters into that new covenant relationship with the LORD.  Verse 16 shows that one day the LORD will command the weeping to cease when the children of Israel are gathered out from the captivity and dispersion back into their homeland.  Verse 17 shows there is hope in the future of the nation of Israel when they come again within their own borders.  Yet for this period of time when Rachel is found weeping in verse 15, there is no comfort.

Matthew’s quotation of this passage does not mean that this is the only place of fulfillment for this prophecy.  Many times throughout Israel’s history have been characterized by unnecessary slaughter of the children of Israel.  Here in Matthew’s passage it is so stark and poignant that he cannot help but quote the prophecy as being fulfilled.  Here the prophecy is overflowing off the pages of scripture right into the hearts of the mothers in Bethlehem and surrounding areas.  There was no comfort for these mothers whose children were mercilessly slaughtered.  Yet it would not be inappropriate to cite this same prophecy as applying to the days when Nebuchadnezzar slaughtered the Israelites in his day, or when Antiochus the IV did so, or even during the holocaust of World War II.  There is even coming a worse time in Israel’s future when the powers of this world will gather together against Jerusalem and attempt to wipe out Israel from being a nation.  Again, there will be no comfort for these mothers until Israel repents, enters into that new covenant relationship with the LORD, and the Davidic Messiah begins to reign.

Matthew did not cherry pick Jeremiah 31:15 to fit his purpose.  Matthew had an understanding of the entire prophecy and we should as well.  Jeremiah and Matthew had the privilege of seeing a future for the nation of Israel when the LORD will command them to stop weeping because there is hope in their future.  For our study here, we would do well not to limit prophecy by making a set of rules that cannot apply uniformly to all situations.  To say that prophecy has only one fulfillment is to ignore this passage and others like it where there is an ongoing fulfillment meant to be brought to an overflowing over an extended period of time.  Further, to say that this passage is completely fulfilled will be to miss the future great tribulation which will include the nation of Israel and further weeping of Rachel as she cries for her children who will simply not be found.

Have fun and stay busy – Luke 19:13

-The Orange Mailman

P.S.  More information on Jeremiah 30-33 can be found at this link here.

This entry was posted in Bible, Eschatology, Fulfilled Prophecy, Pre-Millennialism, Prophecy, The Gospel of Matthew. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Prophecy Unlimited

  1. Vicki Kinsey says:

    I haven’t been keeping up with your posts but happy to see you are. Any decisions on becoming a pastor yet? Maybe you are waiting until you retire from the post office. Keeping you in thought and prayer. Hope your knee is healing quickly and completely with no pain. Love and Hugs. Aunt Vicki

    • Hey Aunt Vicki-

      Thanks for the thoughts and prayers. I’m doing very well considering it’s only been 4 days since my surgery. The decision for me to be a pastor is up to God. Right now there are other things that plainly tell me if it is going to happen that it will be later. Not that it won’t happen, but just not yet. I wait on Him because even though I don’t understand it, His timing is impeccable. Thanks again and I hope Uncle Randy gets back soon.


  2. Pingback: I Will Send My Messenger | The Orange Mailman

  3. Pingback: The Chosen Beloved Servant Who Withdrew Himself | The Orange Mailman

  4. Bea says:

    Regarding Matthew 8:17 when Jesus healed Peters’ mother of the fever… states that ‘the scripture of Isaiah 53: “He bore our sickness and disease…..” WAS FULFILLED. I don’t see where healing is part of the atonement. Peter mentions this and it’s referring to SIN healing not BODY healing.
    When the prophecy of Isa 53 was spoken of the coming Messiah, the way I see it was that Jesus fulfilled all the prophecies spoken of Him to Israel and while He was here, He fulfilled all the law and the prophets. All who were brought to Him were healed. This was for Israel and the Jews to see He was the Messiah and the gospel He taught was about the KINGDOM OF GOD.
    Different time…different group spoken to. Church wasn’t even mentioned. In fact Paul calls the Church/Grace age…….a “mystery hidden from times past.”
    Today, being in the church age or ‘age of grace’ as some call it….except for the Gifts of Healing that the Holy Spirit gives to the church, as He wills for the edification and uplifting of the Body of Christ which can include healing……I don’t think we can say or be praying for someone saying, “by His stripes you are healed”…and if someone isn’t healed, they’re told they have no faith or don’t really believe. this is nonsense!!!!

    I been getting many questions regarding this….so many Christians are confused… many follow various ‘off the wall teachings’…..”thus sayeth the Lord”…..”blood moons being a sign” etc. I could go on, but if one is truly mature and ‘rightly divides the Word of TRUTH….its not complicated at all.

    Anyway, thanks for reading….I just feel sad for what I see the churches doing today…with a watered down gospel….doctrines/teachings of men…..and dear souls sitting in churches week after week and still not hearing the true Gospel of Christ that saves.

    • Hello there, thank you for your comments. I’m not quite sure how to respond. I’m assuming you are referencing my post where Matthew quotes Isaiah 53 in Matthew 8:17. That post can be found at this link here:

      The gospel of Matthew was written to the church long after Pentecost. Matthew references Isaiah 53:4 showing that the physical healing done by Christ fulfilled that passage. There is no way to separate the physical healing that Christ did and the forgiveness of sins into two separate people. It is the same person and the same ministry according to Isaiah 53. I am not saying that when someone is saved from their sins that they receive physical healing. I am saying that Christ came and bore our humanity in its entirety. One day all sickness will be gone because of His redemptive work, but that will be in the age to come.

      Christ came, took on flesh, took human form. It was because of that human form that He was able to bear our sicknesses and pains. It was because of that human form that He was able to die on the cross for ours sins and sinfulness. He came as the Suffering Servant of Isaiah 53 fulfilling the passage. When He spent that evening healing every type of disease and sickness that was presented to Him, the passage was fulfilled. Does that mean it was completed? No. There are many other instances where Jesus healed. Fulfilled means brought to an overflowing, not completed.

      I don’t believe scripture teaches a church/grace age. If you look at the passages that explain the mystery, it is not grace and not the church. Yes, Christ came for the circumcision, see Romans 15:8, but He did it so that Gentiles would rejoice alongside the nation of Israel, see Romans 15:9-12. The church is clearly mentioned in the book of Matthew, see Matthew 16:18, 18:17. Matthew 24:14 shows that the gospel of the kingdom would be preached until the end of the age, cross reference Matthew 28:18-20. We should still be preaching the gospel of the kingdom, which is in essence, repent and believe the gospel, see Mark 1:15.

      Thanks for reading.

      Have fun and stay busy – Luke 19:13

      -The Orange Mailman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s