Is Wealth Redistribution Scriptural?

Do you think the following point of view is scriptural?

If there is someone in your town who is poor, you are to give to them whatever they need. Do not have a hard heart toward your brother. Don’t hold your hand back from giving to him. You are to allow him to borrow what he needs so that the LORD can be generous with you. Any time your neighbor needs to borrow something, open your hand wide and lend him what he wants.

Every seven years, everyone who has someone who in indebted to them must release them from that debt. All creditors must not require what is owed to them in that seventh year. There is to be a remission of all debts to those that live in the same land. Foreigners may be charged what they have borrowed, but those who live among you must be released from all that they have borrowed. If you carefully listen to the LORD and follow what He commands in this, He will bless you so that you will lend to many nations and reign over them. This release is from God and you must obey Him in order to be blessed.

Always lend to whomever is in need. If it is the sixth year, and the next year is the year of release, do not have a worthless thought in your mind saying to yourself, “If I loan to my brother, I will never see this money again because next year is the year of release.” No matter what year it is, you must be generous with your neighbor. Don’t be evil to your brother and deny him the things that he needs because he may cry out to God against you and it will be counted as a sin unto you. You must give cheerfully and then the LORD your God will bless you in everything that you do. There will always be poor people among you and that is why I am commanding you to open your hand freely to the needy.

Those who know the scriptures know that the above is almost word for word out of Deuteronomy 15. I have rearranged the order, but the basic premise is completely scriptural. In light of the above teaching of God’s word, how are we to live our lives in relation to those around us who do not have enough?

There are terms being thrown around disparagingly, many times by Christians, about certain viewpoints. Socialism, Communism, Wealth Redistribution, Hand-Outs, Welfare, Entitlement, Free Health Care, and I got all these from my Christian friends on Facebook. The viewpoint expressed by my Christian friends is something to the effect of: “I worked for my money so why would I give it to someone who doesn’t work?” “Give them someone else’s money and they will vote for you.” Or, my favorite, “Look at how much all that FREE stuff costs.”

So I find myself in a quandary. I see that God’s word says to give to the poor. The act of giving takes place with no strings attached. I give freely because they are in need, and believe me, there are people in true need. I cannot discriminate based on whether or not people have looked for a job, passed a drug test, been irresponsible with money in the past, are living sinful lives, vote a certain way, live in a certain part of town, etc. I could loan them the money, but ultimately I will have to relinquish any right that I have to collect the money. It just seems simpler to give it and not expect anything in return from them, only that God will be faithful to provide for them through me. On the other hand, I have all of my Christian friends posting these cute little sayings on Facebook about, well, see my above list.

This may not be a politically correct post, but here is the way I see this whole matter. I don’t get bent out of shape when I hear about how a political party or a presidential candidate wants to give money to the poor. That is a part of my duty as a Christian. Part of what God blesses me with is commanded by God to go to the poor, see also Deuteronomy 24:19-21. I don’t see why rich people need to hoard their wealth as it creates poor economic conditions. I’m not rich, but I’m not poor either. I have enough money for food, clothes, shelter, and money left over to have a couple of hobbies. There is money enough for me to intentionally give to the poor as long as I set it aside ahead of time. When I get my paycheck, my church, and a couple of other ministries get their money first. Then what is leftover goes to meet my needs, then after that my wants. My church gives to those in need and one of the ministries that I support is specifically for the needy.

This is something that I have been doing for quite some time. God has blessed me since my decision to do this. When I began giving to my church, it didn’t look like I could afford it. God blessed me with a great job with great benefits after I made that decision. I decided at different points in my life to give more and to additional ministries. I also am generous with family members in need. I’m not saying I say yes to every request, but to quite a few of them. All these things are God’s resources and are His to use however He wants. Yes, I use discretion and don’t just give money to every need that pops up.

It troubles me when people who are Christians are posting things from a political viewpoint that almost seems to supersede the Christian viewpoint. Yes, we should be responsible with our money and not throw it away. But Deuteronomy teaches us that giving to the poor is definitely not throwing our money away, but being obedient to God. It’s almost like an investment if you read the chapter in full. We are generous with those around us who are in need, and God is generous with us. How generous do you want God to be with you? Is that reflected in how generous you are with others? Think about it.

Have fun and stay busy – Luke 19:13

-The Orange Mailman


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Is Wealth Redistribution Scriptural?

  1. John (Exo) says:

    I agree. Some thoughts:
    Jesus didn’t come to destroy the law, but to fulfil it. I’m not speaking of the “priestly” add-on laws during OT times. If I understand correctly, the priesthood added numerous “after the fact” interpretations and expansions. My opinion is that those “modifications” were mostly self-serving and had an element of both religious and political control in order for the priesthood to dominate the populace. Jesus did give us proper direction for that circumstance (Matt. 23:1-36).

    As to politicians, I cannot control (a) what they dip out of the public tax monies / create out of thin air (national deficit), (b) to whom they give it, (c) or for what reason in their heart they do it. As elected officials, they are responsible before God for what they do with His money. They will be held accountable. The best I can do is vote for who appears to be Christian.

    I also think there is a wide-spread misapprension of “whose” money we have charge of. We’re stewards of God’s money (if God created all, then “all” is His). Yes, we work and we get a paycheck, but at no time does that become “our” money. In our “Father-and-adopted-child” relationship we are to have a prayerful and discerning attitude of our offerings. “Tithing” is a given; that comes before all else. Offerings should be according to the leading of the Holy Spirit which means we have to be humble and submissive enough to heed the “urging”. (my opinion).

    • Hey thanks. I sort of expected a nasty comment. It’s refreshing to read your perspective.

      Yes, they (politicians) will be held accountable and it’s all God’s money.

      • George says:

        You might want to break down these principles in 2 Thessalonians 3; 6. Who is the disorderly we are to withdraw from? What was Pauls example. 7,-9. What did he command 10. Who is the disorderly in 11? What did he command Christians to do/ 12 What are we to do with those who do onot obey this epistle. Answer note him and have no company with him. Why? So that he may be ashamed. Do not count him as enemy but admonish him as a brother. When God had you give to the poor you did not give it to him, he had to come and pick up the second pickings of grain, fruit, trees, and corners of fields. Welfare today is not the giving of the kind God commanded. The qualification of a widow was for them who had no family to support them. You are only showing one side of Gods commands. You need to show all of it. I gave 65,000 last year and spend time giving to the poor as well as my money but I do not ignore like all of Gods commandments there must be balance. It is not the duty of government to give to the poor, it is the duty of the church. However we must not be enablers. We need to listen to Gods instructions as balance.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s